THE STORYTELLER
ART BY kEN LEHNIG 2004
AFTER ALICE LEFT BY KEN LEHNIG 2003
WITH APOLOGIES TO MR. CARROLL
Scene: Plain stage, hatter and the hare are sitting on two chairs sipping from a bottle, a small table between them. Hatter is wearing a large hat. The hare has large ears.
Hatter: I can't say teatime has been at all pleasant lately. It has left me, the memory, only that I think we enjoyed that time. If in fact we've not even had tea time. On what do you attribute that?
Hare: Right! Nothing!
Hatter: Right…No! Did you hear my question? I've come to believe that the size of your ears are in no way related to what goes into your head.
Hare: I was to the right, at tea, and I attribute nothing …I answered you quite succinctly. Indeed I answered in a very precise way. You see nothing is more annoying than an excessive and obsessive prattler. I have a virtue that allows me to speak in a way that comes right to the point of whatever the matter is. Anything short of that would be uninvited and rude.
Hatter: A virtue… an attribute of yours ?
Hare: Precisely! (Emotive) you are a brilliant man …a man of stature and refinement.
(The Hatter looks in the bottle.)
Hatter: In spite of my brilliance I fear that I have been over shot …(Makes a gesture of it being over his head) I asked…that is …I thought I asked as to what you attribute …
Hare: Yes! ...
Hatter: …the point.
Hare: Waste no time on points they end up being cause for unpleasantness, as you have pointed out.
Hatter: I did?
Hare: Lets get back to your original question…Two…you said attribute it ' two'. That is exactly why things are unpleasant. We have always been two.
Hatter: What I said was, 'On what do you attribute that?'
(Hatter takes a large swig on the bottle)
Hare: Ah! It, that is two, was indicated.
Hatter: We have a grammatical problem.
Hare: That to, but we are still on two. Two is even …that is never at odds…See?
Hatter: Keep going, you are sadly beginning to make sense.
Hare: (Stands up and paces - raised voice) Two must always come to an understanding lest they come at odds. It was Alice, she came uninvited and made us three…odd…and there is the crust of the matter.
Hatter: Crux!
Hare: What? I beg your pardon.
Hatter: No need, Gods speed, let us heed, the acts of misdeeds…(shakes head) You said crust of the matter.
Hare: Yes…crust… that which covers over…to encompass.
Hatter: Do you have one?
Hare: What?
Hatter: A compass perhaps if we could get our bearings we could get clearer on your theory of odds and evens.
Hare: If two, out of discord, become at odds then the two become two -ones …see? Two at odds…with a third acting as mediator. All mediators are odds with an agenda. That’s natural, you see? …When one is left alone- all matter of chatter races back and forth in between their ears…( Twirling hands around ears) crashing and bouncing back and forth…twos and crows, to and fro. Without the calming and sedating benefit of another uninformed mind to agree with you… chaos can not but ensue.
Hatter: And that is bad…all that crashing about? Seems to happen often to me. ( Sips again.)
Hare: Three is the matter. Being pulled this way and that …that way and this…A thing is a thing until something makes it not the thing that it once was.
Hatter: Three the matter for the hatter- to find a ladder- so that he can clatter- up that ladder- to find out what's the matter- with the Hatter and the Hare. In the end the thing can do nothing except to clang a warning- ding- ding- ding.
Hare: When it's we two we must agree lest there be one. If there is three it becomes unbalanced. So we can't be sitting at tea…being balanced.
Hatter: ( Gives bottle to the hare who takes a desperate swig) I truly think you're on to something, but I am feeling a bit unbalanced.
Hare: No…not at tea. Teatime is pleasant and we always do what's pleasant.Madness is sameness and comfortably uncomfortable. Uncertainty must be avoided at all costs. That path leads us to unabashed creativity crashing about without proper control.
Hatter: Unpleasant! ( Takes back the bottle from the agitated Hare )
Hare: Indeed, It may be that we must be doing something unpleasant- thus confusing us and her, our Alice… I see a problem … we are -or were always at tea. We do nothing but tea and we are often as not comfortably confused.
Hatter: Alice has left and we seem to be doing brandy, (Looks at the bottle) and if I may say with some good effect. Although different I think.
Hare: And there is the point.
Hatter: What's the point?
Hare: We are not at tea as you pointedly pointed out.
Hatter: You said that. (Gives him the bottle the hare swigs and hands it back with determination)
Hare: (yelling) Yes I did! And that’s the fudging, fricking, frankan, flacking, flopping point.
Hatter: What point are we on now? I've been taking your advice on points.
Hare: We can assume we are not at tea and we, that is you and I have always been at tea…and we know, as you pointed out…er…as you said, we are now at Brandy. To be at tea is an agitated civilized thing, no one is at Brandy. One can retire to have a brandy.
Hatter: (Looks at the bottle then closes his eyes…opens up) Can't be done… Can't drink when you are sleeping.
Hare: No time …no time ( bouncing about) no time…no resting now. I don't believe we are here. (Runs over and pinches the Hatter who doesn't react) ah ha! There!…eureka!
Hatter: Did you just pinch me? ( rubbing arm)
Hare: We are not here.
Hatter: Not where?
Hare: We are not at tea- we are at brandying…an absurd idea…no matter its good effect. We are definitely not here.
Hatter: If pinching me was in any way used as proof of our existence then you have made an error. I don't have feeling in my arms or legs due to the solution.
Hare: Exactly we need a solution. Brilliant.
Hatter: No I remember a solution. I used a solution.
Hare: (Sitting with gusto) Good… ergo …go ahead. ( Stares intently at the Hatters face.)
Hatter: Go ahead what? ( Backs up)
Hare: Go ahead with your solution.
Hatter: The solution that I used to make hats has made me numb.
Hare: You're mad.
Hatter: No…I'm not angry- I'm numb.
Hare: Ah yes… As the context shifts the layers( Paces) …the layers. Give me the Brandy. (Sips) In the chaos come the answers.
Hatter: (Reaches over and pinches the Hare who jumps up screaming and hopping around.) Are you mad or angry or has spring got you my sad celibate friend.
Hare: I'm angry …angry … and I hurt. (Still howling and hopping) Why did you do that?
Hatter: I was thinking… in an uncharacteristic manner about the argument you presented:
One-Alice caused pleasant to transform to unpleasant.
Two-We are inexplicably not at tea but at brandy.
Three- Alice has gone but may be back
Four- What we will we do pleasantwise or unpleasantwise when she returns is uncertain
and we agree that uncertainty is horrifying.
Five- Am I numb or mad?
Give me that bottle.
Hare: You are both mad and numb. (Sits crossing legs in a huff.)
(Silence)
Hatter: We must be batty. I fear we may be at odds.
(The hare gets up and leaves the stage coming back with a large teapot. He looks in and slams the lid shut)
Hare: Now reality takes a new twist. (He lifts the lid) Chaos!
O.S.V.: Twinkle twinkle little bat how I wonder where you are at.
Hatter: Way up in the sky so high.
Hare: And that is the reason why
Hatter: What reason may I pry?
O.S.V.: Way up in the sky so high like a teacup in the sky
Hare: And that is where the matter lies.( Looks at teapot.)
Hatter: What is in the teapot that you are rude enough not to ask or invite me to partake in?
Hare: Not rude…can't.
Hatter: (Tries to take a drink the bottle is empty.) We are not at tea- we are not brandying. It seems a rather uncertain place. My fall back gives me no spring forward …my vocation was harmful to me…the solution …you see?
Hare: Well I believe that what's in this pot will enlighten us as to our dilemma.
Hatter: What's in the pot?
Hare: A bat.
Hatter: Surely not. Has all reason collapsed? There has always been a door mouse in that pot. A tea addled and drenched mouse.
Hare: Yes and now there is a bat. There is the proof, the solution.
Hatter: That made me numb and mad?
Hare: Don't take numbness for the inability to feel, my friend.
Hatter: I'm hardly sure I understand you. I feel well enough to know your comment was meant as an insult. And so we…(angrily stands) are at odds.
Hare: No we are not.
Hatter: Oh yes. (Louder) We most certainly are.
Hare: (calm) No we are not …we are as even as…
Hatter: (clearly upset) We are …sir …most assuredly and profoundly are at odds…(sighs and sits) Now I've done it. I had a lovely strong horrid feeling and I have lost it.
Hare: Well done, just the same … let's get back to the bat.
Hatter: There once was a man with a hat
Quite pleased he took it off the rack
He heard a story that he took for fact
If you turn your back on your hat
Events may happen and you can't turn back
For in your hat in point of fact may have climbed a nasty, rasty, bat.
Hare: This time it's a teapot.
Hatter: Yes it's very assuredly a teapot. ( He takes off his and looks inside, satisfied, he puts it back on.)
Hare: And in this teapot is the answer to the question of our reality. It is clear that the mouse has turned into a bat. Its survival depended on it. It was in a place, untenable. It sprouted wings to remove itself from a situation in which it could not cope. It evolved, as is the way with the lesser creatures. And therefore Alice is to blame for rampant and chaotic evolution. We were well and good before she came and started changing things, evoluting everything.
Hatter: Evoluting everything! (Looking behind himself) Where are my wings? I'm quite sure that I'm not coping either. All I have is this hat and you …those ridiculous ears that seem not to operate. I assert that Alice brought sense from the senseless…uncertainty from our certainty.
Hare: As you know perfectly well, we were made mad by God in just this perfect form and therefore we are done for. We can't evolve. (Begins to cry) Those who think are doomed. It can't be helped it is written. (Sob through the verse- both bow their heads and put their hands together in prayer)
"If ye be shtinking
From the thinking
Worry about the sinking
Thou should not be blinking
'Cause while God's winking
Woudst have you shrinking
Thou fearest heavens clinking
There will be no changing
For those who woudst be shtinking
From the thinking! Amen"
Hatter: Now! Now! …(Pats Hares head) Lets keep religion out of it. Let's get back to the solution.
Hare: What's the point?
Hatter: The point?
Hare: The point dammit!
Hatter: I, for one, don’t think the points going to be of much use. The solution on the other hand…
Hare: Which hand? (Sniffing loudly)
Hatter: The other one.
Hare: We are clearly now at odds. Are we still talking about your solution?
Hatter: No …that solution was vocational. We are discussing the practical solution pertaining to our current situation.
Hare: As I have thought it out…now mind you I am at odds, and you can't entirely trust my suppositions or conclusions, my conjectures or even my deductions I suspect my premise's are flawed, my speculations askew, and any hypothesis's I may present would totally miss the mark. In short there is no more room. That is to say …Alice came, Alice left and things are a frightful mess, the brandy bottle is empty, and we are left in this sad desolate place. If we can't blame Alice, completely, then…there is no room, no room, no room, no room.
Hatter: No room?
Hare: Exactly…we did it and we have come to the last setting and we are out of tea…and brandy and hope. Off the end.
Hatter: On the other hand.
Hare: Which hand?
Hatter: Pick one and let's get on with it. (Taking off his hat and brushing it with his forearm) You may in fact be right. And right is right and left is left. Wrong is wrong and a song is a song.
Hare: I once knew a man with a hat in his hand
With a reason to stay sloshed all the time
He had a hare for a care to take anywhere
Where a solution might not bend his mind
Hatter: That was quite good. (Hare stands and bows, sits down again) Do you know what happens to a Hatter in time? There are the years of learning just the right way. Then there is the long years of making hats, under proper supervision of course, in just the right way. And in the proper span of time one becomes a Master Hat Maker. You are then responsible for those below you that they make the hats in just the right way. You are called on personally to make the very best hats for the very best people, in just the right way.. Then an extraordinary thing occurs, the solution so necessary for the making of hats as had it's way with you…and you begin to make extraordinary hats in entirely the wrong way. You see…the 'e' in extraordinary is taken off the word 'made' leaving you quite mad.
Hare: How droll (The hare claps, the Hatter stands and bows. Sits and drifts) I remember Spring, A hare only has so many real springs …hopping about hither and yon. Seeking the attention of those of the fairer persuasion. Love to us is as fleeting as it is variety; love heaped upon love for a season and the next and the next and the next…and then the spring will come when we don't hop any more. We become earth bound and wistful…Just a dreadful yearning …only remembering each and every encounter…till we remember the very last one.
Hatter: Have you come to it, dear friend …should we make arrangements?
Hare: It is close I fear. But arrangements won't help…even lovely bouquets will not make me one bit less sad.
Hatter: Then we are doomed for I could not be left "one". We are not at odds dear friend. We will never be at odds.
Hare: Good, thank you for that honor. my dearest friend…but do you agree that we are most certainly doomed?
Hatter: On one hand 'yes' on the other well…still yes (Starts crying which starts the Hare to weeping as well)
Hare: We are tea-less and brandy-less and hopeless. (Both are bawling)
Enter Tweedle Dum and Tweedle Dee… they are emperious in manner acting put out by the crying. Both are wearing Napoleonic Hats, sash-ed and medal- ed to the point of silliness.
Tdee: See hear… if you would but stop this unseamly display we could be about our business with you.
Tdum: Yes… it's most unseamly-wise to come into an emotional outbreak and not be privy to its cause.
(The Hare and the Hatter are unable to settle down)
Tdee: Oh my…both of you need to gather yourselves up…
Hare: Ridiculous…we can't gather ourselves up for there most certainly (sniff) is only one of me and certainly only one of him. How or what in the unraveling world do we gather up?
Hatter: It must (wipes nose with his sleeve) be trouble w-w-w-w-when these two show up it generally …
Tdee: Admirals if you don’t mind.
Hare: Admirals?
Tdum: We want you two to be our Generals.
Tdee: Yes, Generals in the upcoming …that is shortly going to…
Tdum: We are about to start a war.
(Both the Hatter and the Hare stare at them.)
Hatter: it seems to me that you two were always about and about and about some issue concerning …dare I say it?
Hare: Oh do …we need a lark.
Hatter: I need a Lark to mention a rattle?
Tdee: (Screaming in fury) He has the rattle and refuses to give it to me. He knows perfectly well that I as the first born am entitled to it as my soul possession…and he lies and he ef-u-scates, oooo-ridgibates and desa-tates and other wise creates a condition equal to a mal-fuuuu-sin-ational abry-cation that is intolerable. (Sits on the floor in a huff)
Hare: (To Hare ) Well done. (To Tdum) Do you have it?
Tdum: What?
Hatter: The Ef-u-scating rattle.
Tdum: (whispering) Shhhh! I do have it…I just enjoy it so much
when he does that.
(The Hatter and the Hare nod)
Hare: Well it seems easy enough …give him back his rattle.
Tdum: Oh…if only it was that easy…I've let it go too long now. Having it was fun because he would stomp around demanding and pleading. Having the rattle is no longer the issue …I have become insulted by the manner in which he begs and pleads. I no longer care about what he has or has not. (Loudly) I therefore officially deny that I possess the rattle.
Hare: It's the even and odd thing…Alice…She talked to them. Tea…Brandy…War. Chaos! (Hatter nods)
Hatter: Seems a rather large jump.
Hare: I choose not to be insulted by that…Jump indeed…making fun of a persons infirmity
Tdum: There is nothing more important than war.
Hatter: Over a rattle?
Tdee: (Standing) It's a very valuable rattle. I'm not sure, dear so, that the you are of a mind to fathom the dimbimplecity the concentric eddies in the space time continuum warranting the conversion that facilitates such actions,
Hare: So we are to be Generals and you are Admirals?
Hatter: I see a problem… You two have no sea. We two have no armies. Rattle or no…I
think there will be no war . And we are left with the original dilemma no tea and no brandy.
Hare: Did any one of you mention the rattle to Alice? (To the twins)
Tdum: Maybe in passing.
Tdee: We may have alluded.
Hare: Before you met Alice were you congenial?
Tdee: Oh indeed quite polite and congenial…dear me he is my brother.
Hare: Even though you knew that one of you had the rattle?
Tdum: Yes…we are both horrid pathofanatic liars, as well as being irresponsible, egocenentric...
Tdee: ...delightful conversationalists, witty, moderately handsome, and completely suited to our profession.
Tdum: We have the best credentials. (Reaches in his coat and pulls out a bottle of brandy, hands it to the hatter who grins opens it and drinks) And I think we can get this war on the right track.
Hare: Have you told the Queens?
Tdee: The Queens are for …for whatever side wins.
Hatter: The Kings?
Tdum: The Kings have always done best by agreeing with the Queens.
Hatter: Bishop?
Tdee: Ah, there is the rub. As far as our sources tell us, espionage-wise, everyone here is of the same religion. Therefore no one feels a need to fight over anything worth dying.
Tdum: Well, as I have often spoke, this idea of freedom is a breeding ground for uncertainty. If we could but put a true caste system back into place, with proper rich and proper poor. Then the poor would be trapped in a blissful place of certainty in their inability to change a thing about their lives.
Hatter: You silk laden puffs forget that I was a working man, a guild member.
Hare: And should a caste system be put into place I would be in a stew.
Tdum: So what better work for you both than being Generals?
Hatter: You two would not work?
Tdee: Advise! You must have faith that your betters no the correct way.
Hare: (To the Hatter) My theory proven again. (Hatter nods and passes the bottle)
Hatter: How's that, pray tell?
Hare: Not faith my dear…but truth…The truth!
Tdee: I for one am a firm believer in the truth. One cannot function with absurdities flying about…hither-skither…
Tdum: Oh indeed not…one could become unhinged …as it were.
Hatter: "Tis either an objective truth or a subjective truth. I think, that all there is …is subjective truths. And I do believe, my dear Generals…
Tdee, Tdum: Admirals!
Hatter: Thank you, it is an admirable thought …and true enough for this conversation.
Hare: You must believe in something, I can't imagine believing in nothing.
Tdee: That is close to blasphemy.
Hatter: Follow me…(All stand up, the hatter is only adjusting his coat, and the others start to walk off stage) No, no sit please I meant follow my thinking. Truth must appear to be objective that way we are cozy and safe… no hithering and skithering about. But truth is much more evasive than we can tolerate.
Tdum: Look here, I'm becoming quite angry at this talk. We have perfectly good priests and doctors taking quite good care of the truth. And we should be thankful they are there.
Hatter: Oh I agree…but imagine how annoying it must be for the' truth' to be constantly made to be argued about and amended with each new turn of the sun. There are pesky things that are being found every day upsetting the apple cart. And those of us who are not priests or doctors are left to 'Believe' pretty much as we please. That is disturbing and uncomfortable. I'm little enamored of the objective truths.
Hare: Too much memorization. History was my worst subject. I wasn't bad at math …1+1+1+1+1 equals in a good Spring a hundred…more if I wasn't too tired. ( Humping the air.)
Hatter: Tea …Brandy…Time for tea and brandy fine diddle dee dee…all good enough for me.
Hare: We are all like great balloons adrift with tethered anchors grasping the ground where we can find any purchase. Where we are connected- is the truth and then some great storm sends us aloft again…or we die and none of it maters…Except to hares and hatters…and Admirals too.
Tdee: You have given me a headache.
Hatter: My dears that is your job…see?…If too many have their tethers down and will not see the new objective truth you espouse, either, you must break the tethers with fine speech making and politics having them see their folly or cut them loose permanently! (Takes off hat and takes a swig of brandy.) Silencing is the tool of the foolish and the mighty. Be it the machinations of one or the will of a nation 'tis a grand tool.
Hare: My friend is mad, quite insane. And only a mad man could see the truth in it and he is right. Should we go to war over a rattle or is it the apple cart that’s been turned over and we have no one to blame?
Hatter: If one were to take it from a geopolitical perspective. War becomes not an invention but a reaction to conditions associated with, culture, religious tensions, weather, crop viability, population density, disease, famine, and migration. These conditions cause time sensitive stressors; the need for war becomes a release valve to decrease population; the destruction of all the progenitors, i.e. males, on all sides and to allow surviving women and children to be assimilated into other base populations. The destruction allows for unfettered economic development, a more balanced cultural and ethnic stratum creating a multigenerational civic system more in keeping with well though tout and established paradigms.
( All just stare at the Hatter)
Tdum: It is far worse than I first believed my brothers. Alice has spread an insidious form of thought so insidious that the insidiousness of it is so insidious…
Hare: Demonizing! ( whispers to Hatter)
Tdee: We can ill afford this insidious thinking to spread throughout the land. We must marshal our forces and perfect a plan to figure out the best way to fight this insidiousness.
Hare: Good! Good! (Pacing) First hire a Marshall as you rightly suggested, then have him eliminate any one thinking in an insidious way.
Tdum: Good! Good! (Pacing) Then as the insidious thinking begins to spread, which of course it will. We will prepare for a real war. It's only logical that once people start thinking in an inappropriate way. The only way to galvanize those rampant thoughts is a delightful war.
Hare: Sophistry! (Whispers to Hatter)
Hatter: Did he hear what I said earlier? ( The Hare shakes his head)
Tdee: Yes, One not over trivial rattles…you still have it…
Tdum: Do not.
Tdee: But a war based on the truest of ideals and precepts of faith inherent in the objective truth that the priests and doctors under our influence and command will write down as the Word of law . Oh …I shiver at the beauty of it.
Hare: Dillusional! (Whispers to Hatter)
(Hatter, nods, buffs his hat then takes another swig)
Tdum: It is time for a new order. A clean and tidy society, everything in its place, a placefor everything.
Hare: Obsessive! ( Whispers to Hatter)
Tdum: You hatter shall become not a General but the Minister of Truth. And you Hare… Minister of the New Science.
Hatter: Do I have to do anything? I want to hire a Marshall that can be paid off. Like in a civilized society.
Hare: I'll make it up and you determine whether it's subjective or objective …you tell them …they tell the people. Whoever doesn't believe it is ruined or silenced or has to pay the Marshall. Right Hatter? Do I have it right gentlemen? ( Elbowing the Hatter and winking)
Tdum &Tdee: Exactly! And if another nation tries to tell us we are wrong in our thinking then It's war.
Hatter: The Queens and Kings?
Tdum: They have no time for thinking. This way they don't have to think at all …lord love a duck, they will love it. And the Queen of Hearts will relish the idea of silencing any one we send her.
Tdee: Who shall be the Marshall?
Hare: How about that sniveling, fat assed, two faced, addle-minded, cousin of mine the White Rabbit. He hasn't a thought of his own and any one we give him will suit him fine.
( Slapping his knee in delight.)
Hatter: I am out of Brandy…and I believe it's time for tea.
Hare, Tdum, Tdee: So it is, so it is.
Hatter: Then let's be about finding some tea…or vodka…more brandy would be nice.
( Both the Hatter and the Hare remain seated as the Admirals quietly argue then begin to leave the stage.)
Hare: I feel better.
Hatter: I'm most certainly insane. My dear Hare, our conversations are certainly more entertaining. Those two are daft and any solution of any type is very far from them.
Hare: My word, you sound absolutely lucid.
Hatter: Is there still a bat in the teapot? (Hare looks and slams the lid down.) What's in there now?
( Hatter sits down.)
Hare: Nothing!
Hatter: (Takes a big swig off the new bottle) Should you look again?
Hare: No, God knows what will be in there now.
Hatter: I wonder if Alice will ever come back . I rather liked her.( Taking a sip and handing it to the Hare)
(The Admirals ignoring the Hatter and Hare…leaving the stage.)
Tdee: You still have the rattle.
Tdum: Do not.
Tdee: Do too.
(dark stage)
The end.
Hallman and Lehnig Dolls (c)1994